← Back to Recently Funded

Recently Funded

Underwriting Case Study

Mississauga Pre-Construction Purchase with Appraisal Shortfall

Clients purchasing a pre-construction property in Mississauga faced an appraisal shortfall because the appraised value came in below the purchase price. They needed additional down payment funds and owned another property with strong equity. A quick private mortgage appeared attractive at first, but the payment from that mortgage would have pushed their debt-service ratios outside the bank’s limits for the new purchase. HopeWell instead arranged an A-lender refinance on the existing property at a low rate and then arranged the purchase mortgage with the same lender, allowing the clients to access equity while keeping ratios in line.

Details are anonymized to protect client, lender, investor, and transaction privacy. This case is for general education only and is not a commitment to lend, a guarantee of approval, or legal, tax, or financial advice.

1. Executive Summary

Clients purchasing a pre-construction property in Mississauga faced an appraisal shortfall because the appraised value came in below the purchase price. They needed additional down payment funds and owned another property with strong equity. A quick private mortgage appeared attractive at first, but the payment from that mortgage would have pushed their debt-service ratios outside the bank’s limits for the new purchase. HopeWell instead arranged an A-lender refinance on the existing property at a low rate and then arranged the purchase mortgage with the same lender, allowing the clients to access equity while keeping ratios in line.

2. Borrower Profile

The borrowers were existing homeowners purchasing a new pre-construction property. Their identity, income, purchase price, appraised value, existing property value, mortgage amount, and down payment amount are not disclosed. The underwriting issue was the interaction between the appraisal shortfall, equity access, and debt-service ratios.

3. Property Profile

The purchase property was a pre-construction residential property in Mississauga, Ontario. The clients also owned an existing residential property with significant equity. Exact addresses, values, lender names, and mortgage amounts are not disclosed.

4. The Challenge

The clients owned another property with significant equity and initially wanted a quick private mortgage to access funds for the additional down payment. However, when the private mortgage payment was added to their liabilities, the clients no longer qualified for the new purchase mortgage with the bank.

5. Why Conventional Solutions Failed

The obvious quick solution was to place a private mortgage on the existing property to raise the shortfall funds. However, mortgage underwriting is not only about whether funds can be accessed. The new payment created by that financing must also be included in the borrower’s liabilities. Once the private mortgage payment was included, the clients no longer qualified for the new purchase mortgage with the bank. This meant the private mortgage would solve the down payment problem but create a qualification problem.

6. Our Analysis

HopeWell analyzed the file as a two-property qualification problem. The first question was how much equity could be accessed from the existing property. The second question was whether the resulting payment would allow the clients to still qualify for the new purchase mortgage. The third question was whether an A-lender refinance could access the necessary funds at a lower rate and lower payment than private financing. By testing the ratios under different structures, HopeWell identified that an A-lender refinance on the existing property created a better overall approval path than a private mortgage.

7. Financing Structure

The file was structured using an A-lender refinance on the clients' existing property and a purchase mortgage on the new pre-construction property. The same lender was used for the new property mortgage. Exact rates, mortgage amounts, appraised values, purchase price, and lender name are not disclosed.

8. Why the Solution Worked

The solution worked because it addressed both parts of the problem: the clients needed more down payment, and they also needed to remain within debt-service ratio guidelines. A private mortgage may have been faster, but the higher payment made the purchase mortgage harder to qualify for. The lower-rate A-lender refinance allowed equity access while keeping the payment low enough for the overall ratios to remain acceptable.

9. Key Lessons

  • When appraisal is lower than purchase price, the borrower may need to increase the down payment.
  • Using equity from another property can help, but the new payment must be included in mortgage qualification.
  • A private mortgage can solve a cash shortfall but may create debt-service ratio issues.
  • The cheapest or lowest-payment structure can sometimes be more important than the fastest structure.
  • When two properties are involved, both the equity plan and the purchase approval must be analyzed together.

10. Related HopeWell Resources

Related Guide

Related Service

Related Calculator

Related Mortgage Dictionary Terms

Related Funded Cases

Suggested Diagrams

  • Appraisal shortfall diagram showing purchase price, appraised value, lender value, and required additional down payment
  • Before-and-after financing structure comparing private mortgage vs A-lender refinance
  • Two-property debt-service ratio diagram
  • Equity take-out flow diagram showing existing property refinance funding new purchase down payment

Real-world experience

Related underwriting case studies

Explore anonymized Ontario mortgage files that show how borrower circumstances, property details, lender policy, costs, and exit strategy can interact.

View all case studies →
Recently FundedMississauga

Mississauga Purchase Approved Through a Low-LTV Equity Program

A couple in Mississauga sold their existing home and were purchasing a new home. They had significant equity from the sale, which created a low loan-to-value purchase. However, the husband was self-employed and declared limited income on his T1s, while the wife was not employed and received child tax benefits. The clients had been told that private lending was their only option. The clients were approved through a near-A lender instead of using a private mortgage.

Solution
Near-A / alternative institutional mortgage
Purpose
Purchase
Mississaugaself-employed mortgagelow declared income
Read the case study
Recently FundedMississauga

Mississauga A-Lender Approval with Seasonal Income, EI, Low YTD, CCB and Basement Rent

Mississauga clients had a complicated but explainable income file. The wife was not working. The husband earned a strong income as a heavy machinery operator, but his hours were not guaranteed, so the lender could not simply annualize the hourly rate. His work also shut down for roughly three months each year because of snow, during which he received EI. In the current year, his YTD income was low because he missed around four months of work due to a back injury. We approached an A lender, explained the full context, and obtained an exception on the low YTD income. The bank used average T4 income, included average EI income, and also considered eligible CCB and basement rental income.

Solution
A-lender mortgage approval
Purpose
A-lender income exception and mortgage qualification
Mississauga OntarioA-lender approvalincome exception
Read the case study
Recently FundedMississauga

Mississauga Private Mortgage for Foreign Self-Employed Income and Business Investment

A client in Mississauga owned a business in Nigeria and wanted to access approximately $400,000 of home equity to invest back into that business. The file was difficult because the income was foreign self-employed income. Conventional lenders may be more comfortable with foreign salaried income where employment can be verified, but foreign self-employed income is much harder to use. The file also had a use-of-funds challenge because the mortgage proceeds were intended to leave Canada. The property had a very low loan-to-value, so we arranged a private mortgage supported by the collateral strength.

Solution
Private mortgage
Purpose
Equity take-out for foreign business investment
Mississauga Ontarioforeign self-employed incomeNigeria business
Read the case study
Recently FundedMississauga

Mississauga Power of Sale Rescue with Prepaid Private Mortgage

A Mississauga couple came to us while their home was in power of sale. Both husband and wife were working and earning decent income, but because of spending and unsecured debt issues, they had accumulated significant credit card debt and fell behind badly enough for the property to enter power of sale. Power of sale is not just a mortgage problem; it can be emotionally devastating because a family may lose the home, the memories attached to it, and the equity built over many years. We arranged a prepaid private mortgage that paid out the existing mortgages. The mortgage was prepaid for one year so the clients had breathing room to pay down unsecured debts. We also counselled them to get rid of their credit cards and avoid rebuilding the same debt. After one year, if the debts are paid down and the file improves, the plan is to revisit a B-lender refinance and eventually work toward A-lender financing again.

Solution
Prepaid private mortgage
Purpose
Power of sale rescue, existing mortgage payout, debt stabilization, and refinance planning
Mississauga Ontariopower of saleprivate mortgage
Read the case study
Recently FundedHamilton

Hamilton Purchase Approved with 100% Foreign Income and Dubai Sale Proceeds Down Payment

Hamilton clients were purchasing their primary residence in Canada. The husband worked as a commercial pilot for a major international airline and lived in Dubai, while the wife lived in Canada and was not working. The two major underwriting issues were that 100% of the income was foreign income and 100% of the down payment was coming from the sale of a property in Dubai. The clients wanted 80% LTV. Most A lenders were only comfortable up to approximately 65% LTV for this type of file. We approached almost every A lender in the broker network to request an exception for 80% LTV. The next practical option was a B lender. The B lender considered the foreign income through the husband’s job letter, pay stubs, and three months of bank statements showing salary deposits. For down payment, we submitted the Dubai sale deed, copy of bank draft, and bank statement showing deposit of the sale proceeds.

Solution
B-lender purchase mortgage
Purpose
Purchase mortgage using foreign income and Dubai property sale proceeds
Hamilton Ontariopurchase mortgageB-lender approval
Read the case study
Recently FundedVaughan

Vaughan Preconstruction Purchase Closed with Open Private Mortgage and Sale Exit

A Vaughan client had entered into a preconstruction purchase after advice from friends. He soon realized that he could neither qualify for the required mortgage nor afford to keep the home. Based on his income, he would not qualify with an A lender or B lender. His goal became to close the purchase and then sell the property. We arranged a short-term open private mortgage so he could close the transaction. The open mortgage was recommended because he planned to sell the home and did not want to face a prepayment penalty when repaying the mortgage after sale.

Solution
Private mortgage
Purpose
Short-term open private mortgage to close preconstruction purchase and allow sale-based exit
Vaughan Ontariopreconstruction purchaseprivate mortgage
Read the case study