A first purchase that needed a different financing structure
Two first-time buyers wanted to purchase a home in Scarborough with a 20% down payment. Both operated a business through a general partnership, and a substantial portion of its receipts arrived in cash. The records available for mortgage underwriting did not demonstrate enough qualifying income for the A- or B-lender financing they needed.
By the time our assessment was complete, the buyers had made the purchase firm. A private mortgage at their original leverage would have been unaffordable for them. Increasing the down payment to 25%, with help from a brother’s gift, opened a more manageable private option and allowed the purchase to proceed.
Two buyers earning income through a general partnership
The applicants earned their income from the same general partnership. Although they deposited cash receipts, some funds went into personal chequing accounts, and the business-account deposits did not provide sufficient support for the requested mortgage.
The issue was the income that could be established from the available evidence. The fact that a business receives cash does not, by itself, indicate improper reporting or make its income unusable. It does make clear records especially valuable: the lender needs to understand which receipts belong to the business, the expenses incurred and the income attributable to each applicant.
A Scarborough purchase with the agreement already firm
This was a residential purchase in Scarborough intended to become the applicants’ first home. The purchase agreement was already firm when the income assessment established that the original financing plan would not work. That made the funding decision more urgent, because the applicants had committed to the transaction.
The property address, purchase price and mortgage amount are withheld. The published case focuses on the financing change rather than identifying the borrowers or their home.
The available records did not support the required mortgage
The file contained two connected constraints. The income evidence available did not support the amount required through an A or B lender, while the private financing considered at the original 20% down payment was too costly for the applicants. Simply changing lender categories would not produce a suitable result.
The question became whether the buyers could contribute more equity and access a different private option with costs they could manage. A solution also needed an honest plan for what would happen after closing, because completing the purchase would not automatically resolve the income-documentation issue.
Why 20% down did not solve the income issue
A 20% down payment leaves 80% of the purchase price to finance before fees and adjustments. The applicants still need to qualify for that mortgage amount. In this assessment, the combination of business and personal account deposits did not demonstrate sufficient qualifying income for the required A- or B-lender loan.
An alternative lender may assess self-employed income differently from a bank, but it still needs a supportable case. Our assessment identified the gap between what the business was earning and what the available records could establish for this purchase. That gap determined the financing options we could realistically pursue.
Finding a workable option by increasing the down payment
We reviewed the effect of increasing the buyers’ contribution by another five percentage points. A lender available for this file offered a private option with pricing closer to the B-lending options considered and a comparatively low lender fee. The larger down payment made that option available to these borrowers.
Their brother gifted the additional funds, bringing the down payment from 20% to 25%. The change reduced the purchase-price funding requirement from 80% to 75%, before fees and other adjustments. That is purchase-price arithmetic, not an independently verified final LTV: a lender’s approved value and mortgage advance determine its actual ratio.
The improvement was specific to this transaction. Another applicant cannot assume that five additional percentage points will produce the same lender choice or pricing. A meaningful comparison considers the mortgage payment, fees and costs over the intended borrowing period, together with the ability to repay or refinance at the end.
We also addressed the income trail. The advice was to deposit business receipts consistently into the business account and build a clearer record for a future lending review. CRA guidance supports recording cash income and keeping original evidence. Deposits should connect to underlying sales and expenses; transferring money between accounts does not create new business income.
A family gift, 25% down and a private mortgage
The completed purchase used private financing with a 25% down payment, including the additional contribution gifted by the applicants’ brother. The selected option offered a more manageable structure than the private financing considered with only 20% down. No interest rate, fee amount, mortgage term or monthly payment is published.
The longer-term objective was a B-lender refinance the following year, supported by improved documentation of the business income. That was an exit objective, not an approved future mortgage. Eligibility would still depend on acceptable income evidence, the borrowers’ financial position, property value and lender requirements when a new application was assessed.
Closing the purchase with a clearer path for the next review
The added equity changed the financing choices available at closing. At the same time, the applicants received a practical task for the period ahead: make their business income easier to trace and assess. Those were separate pieces of work. The gift helped the purchase close; consistent, supported records could help a future lender understand the partnership.
FSRA’s guidance explains why private borrowing needs a realistic exit strategy and a backup plan. For a borrower in a similar position, progress should be reviewed before maturity. If the planned refinance cannot be supported, the available repayment or renewal alternatives need to be examined while there is still time to act.
Lessons for self-employed first-time buyers
- Have self-employed income assessed before making a purchase firm whenever possible; a substantial down payment does not settle income qualification.
- Keep a clear connection between business receipts, account deposits, expenses and each partner’s income.
- A larger down payment can change available financing, but the effect is specific to the borrower, property and lender.
- Family assistance should be a genuine gift on terms acceptable to the lender; a repayable advance creates a different obligation.
- Treat a future B-lender refinance as a conditional exit plan with measurable documentation improvements and a backup strategy.
Questions this case helps answer
Can first-time buyers with partnership income get a mortgage?
Yes, the business structure does not itself determine the lender category. The lender must be able to assess the applicants’ income and the rest of the application. These buyers required private financing because the evidence then available did not support their requested A- or B-lender mortgage.
Why did increasing the down payment from 20% to 25% help?
It reduced the amount of the purchase price requiring financing and made a different private option available for this file. Before fees and adjustments, the price-financing requirement moved from 80% to 75%. Another lender’s valuation and conditions may produce a different outcome.
Does depositing cash into a business account guarantee mortgage qualification?
No. Deposits help establish a trail, but a lender also needs to understand their source, the related expenses and the income available to each borrower. CRA business-record guidance calls for recording cash income and supporting entries with original documents. Mortgage eligibility remains a separate lender assessment.
Was the B-lender refinance for the following year guaranteed?
No. It was the intended next step if the applicants could establish an acceptable income record and meet the future lender’s requirements. The new mortgage would require a fresh review. The private mortgage still needed to be repaid or otherwise addressed if that refinance could not proceed.
Related guides and funded cases
- Self-employed mortgages in Ontario
Review how business income can be presented for mortgage assessment.
- Mortgage broker in Scarborough
Explore local guidance for purchases and complex income situations.
- Self-employed income explained
Understand the difference between business receipts and qualifying income.
- Gifted down payments
Learn about family gifts, documentation and lender requirements.
- Private mortgage exit strategies
Build a conditional refinance plan with practical milestones.
- Private mortgage exit planner
Explore repayment needs and potential refinancing gaps.
- Markham private-to-B-lender refinance
Compare a completed refinance supported by business bank statements.
- Caledon self-employed first-time buyers
Read a contrasting purchase where supported self-employed income fit insured lending.
Sources and further reading
Official guidance supporting the general principles discussed in this case. The transaction narrative is based on HopeWell’s funded-file account.
- Canada Revenue Agency: business records
Official guidance on recording cash income and retaining supporting documents.
- FSRA: private mortgages
Consumer guidance on private borrowing costs, exit strategies and backup plans.